Tasmania Government Falls as Speaker Casts Decisive Vote in No-Confidence Motion
Tasmania's Liberal minority government collapsed Thursday when Labor Speaker Michelle O'Byrne used her casting vote to pass a no-confidence motion against Premier Jeremy Rockliff, setting the state on course for its second election in 14 months.
The dramatic vote in the House of Assembly ended 18-17 after O'Byrne broke a 17-17 tie by voting with her Labor Party colleagues, despite holding the traditionally impartial Speaker's chair since 2024.
"Under the provisions of Standing Order 167, and with reference to the commitment given when I was elected to the Chair, I cast my vote with the ayes," O'Byrne told the packed chamber after delivering an eight-minute explanation of her decision.
The vote immediately triggered constitutional processes that will likely force Tasmanians to the polls again, less than 15 months after the March 2024 election that left no party with a clear majority in the expanded 35-seat parliament.
Truth matters. Quality journalism costs.
Your subscription to Mencari directly funds the investigative reporting our democracy needs. For less than a coffee per week, you enable our journalists to uncover stories that powerful interests would rather keep hidden. There is no corporate influence involved. No compromises. Just honest journalism when we need it most.
Not ready to be paid subscribe, but appreciate the newsletter ? Grab us a beer or snag the exclusive ad spot at the top of next week's newsletter.
Premier Jeremy Rockliff, who has led a minority government with just 14 Liberal members, declared the outcome "a very sad day for Tasmania" and vowed to fight any subsequent election campaign.
"I will advise the Governor of the vote in the House and the context of it," Rockliff said in an emotional 15-minute response. "I will also advise if Mr Winter cannot command a majority in this place, most reluctantly, we would need to go to an election."
The no-confidence motion was moved by Opposition Leader Dean Winter, whose Labor Party holds 10 seats in the current parliament. The Greens, with five members, supported the motion, while two crossbench members voted with the government.
O'Byrne's decision to vote against the government she technically serves under parliamentary convention sparked immediate controversy. The Speaker acknowledged the extraordinary nature of her position in lengthy remarks explaining her vote.
"When I was elected to this position it was made clear to this House and the public that despite no longer attending the caucus and strategy meetings of the Labor Party that I would always vote with them," O'Byrne said.
The Speaker, who has served in parliament since 1998 across federal and state levels, defended her partisan approach by citing Tasmania's unique political culture and the frequency of tied votes in the small parliament.
"No one in this chamber could realistically expect me to provide confidence to a Liberal government," she said. "No one would expect me to turn my back on the rules of a party that I have believed in my entire life and been a member of for longer than some members of this chamber have actually been alive."
O'Byrne referenced precedent from previous Tasmanian parliaments, noting that Speakers from both major parties had historically voted with their parties on crucial matters, including confidence motions that changed governments.
However, the Speaker also hinted at her own future, saying she had "reflected not only on my appointment as Speaker but my continuing future in this House and I will have more to say about that in coming days."
The vote came during budget week, with O'Byrne warning that parliament must urgently reconvene to pass supply bills to fund government services beyond July 1, 2025. She noted that automatic supply provisions would only last approximately two months.
"It is imperative that Parliament resumes, so it can consider and approve appropriate supply bills to fund government services before 1 July 2025," the Speaker said.
Premier Rockliff used his post-vote speech to attack Winter's leadership and defend his government's 14-month record, particularly regarding the controversial AFL stadium project that has dominated Tasmanian politics.
"I believe in this team so passionately because it's working now," Rockliff said, referring to Tasmania's planned AFL franchise. "Young kids right now believe and are aspiring. It's created an energy."
The Premier criticized what he called "the personalisation of the vote" and accused Labor of pursuing "a selfish grab for power."
"I'll be damned if the Labor Party is going to choose the leader of the Liberal Party that I love," Rockliff declared.
The government's troubles have mounted in recent months over budget pressures, the handling of the AFL stadium project, and questions about potential privatization of state-owned enterprises. The Premier had faced criticism over cost blowouts and delivery issues with the proposed Macquarie Point stadium in Hobart.
Rockliff acknowledged his government's challenges but defended its collaborative approach in the minority parliament setting.
"We've got most of our agenda through simply because of our negotiations between each other," he said. "And that's why I'm so disappointed, if not broken hearted, frankly, of what the Tasmanian people who elected us in March 2024 to work together."
The Premier thanked crossbench members who supported his government, specifically naming Ms. Pentland and Ms. Beswick for "being responsible" and "representing your electorates in the best interests of Tasmania."
Opposition Leader Winter had not announced whether he would attempt to form a minority government, with Rockliff noting Winter's previous statements about not doing deals with the Greens.
"I saw the Honourable Member's statement today where he would not do a deal with the Greens. Well, what's this all about?" Rockliff questioned.
The Premier confirmed his team would return to parliament in coming days to ensure government services continue through supply bills, criticizing what he called Winter's "recklessness" in forcing the vote during budget deliberations.
"Our team will be back in here in the coming days to provide our nurses, our teachers, our paramedics, our child protection officers and police men and women with the certainty that the Leader of the Opposition has robbed of them with his selfish actions this week," Rockliff said.
The constitutional crisis now moves to Government House, where Lieutenant Governor Margaret Crawford will need to determine whether Winter can command majority support in the House of Assembly or whether fresh elections are necessary.
Tasmania's political instability comes at a challenging time, with the state facing budget pressures and uncertainty over major infrastructure projects including the Marinus Link energy cable to mainland Australia.
The expanded 35-seat House of Assembly was implemented following reforms championed by Rockliff when the Liberals held majority government, aimed at improving representation and parliament's functionality.
"It wasn't easy to get a 35-seat parliament through my team. But I knew it was the right thing to do. And I still believe it was the right thing to do," the Premier said.
The March 2024 election delivered a hung parliament with the Liberals winning 14 seats, Labor 10, the Greens five, and six crossbench members including three from the Jacqui Lambie Network.
Rockliff's minority government had survived for 14 months through careful negotiation and compromise with crossbench members, delivering what the Premier described as outcomes for all parties represented in parliament.
However, mounting pressures over the AFL stadium project, budget constraints, and questions about asset sales ultimately proved fatal when combined with Labor's determination to force a confidence vote.
The timing of any election will depend on the Lieutenant Governor's assessment of whether an alternative government can be formed, though political observers suggest fresh polls appear inevitable given the parliamentary arithmetic.
If elections proceed, they would mark Tasmania's second trip to the polls in just over a year, an outcome Rockliff predicted would anger voters already dealing with cost-of-living pressures.
"Make no mistake, this will be an election that Tasmanians don't want and Tasmania cannot afford, but be that on Mr Winters and the Labor Party's head," the Premier concluded.
The dramatic scenes in parliament Thursday represent the culmination of months of political tension in Australia's island state, where the small size of parliament often magnifies political conflicts and makes stable government challenging to maintain.
Got a News Tip?
Contact our editor via Proton Mail encrypted, X Direct Message, LinkedIn, or email. You can securely message him on Signal by using his username, Miko Santos.
As well as knowing you’re keeping MENCARI alive, you’ll also get:
Get breaking news AS IT HAPPENS - Gain instant access to our real-time coverage and analysis when major stories break, keeping you ahead of the curve
Unlock our COMPLETE content library - Enjoy unlimited access to every newsletter, podcast episode, and exclusive archive—all seamlessly available in your favorite podcast apps.
Join the conversation that matters - Be part of our vibrant community with full commenting privileges on all content, directly supporting Mencari's
Not ready to be paid subscribe, but appreciate the newsletter ? Grab us a beer or snag the exclusive ad spot at the top of next week's newsletter.
